Reviewed by A N Wilson
We've made some changes
to The Sunday Times
There has not been anything quite like it since the crowds waited agog on the quayside at New York harbour in 1841, to learn, from the final episode of The Old Curiosity Shop, whether Little Nell lived or died. Of course, the excitement, then as now, was commercially generated. But the hundreds of thousands of families who have, since midnight on July 20, been obsessed by the contents of the volume under review, were not grabbing the book out of one another’s hands as a publicity stunt. We have all been on a long journey together, with JK Rowling weaving her spell over our minds, just like one of the teachers at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, which Harry first attended at the age of 11.
The pure unalloyed enjoyment of the earlier books was of course darkened as soon as the story took us beyond Hogwarts to the other areas of the magical world – that very uninnocent place where Rita Skeeter writes her sensationalist drivel for The Daily Prophet, the Ministry of Magic allows itself to be infiltrated by the forces of darkness, the victims of malice – such as Neville Longbottom’s parents – languish as maimed patients for life in St Mungo’s Hospital, and the few who join the resistance, the Order of the Phoenix, huddle in the dingy “safe house” of Number Twelve, Grimmauld Place.
By the close of the sixth book, however, even school has lost its glow. Albus Dumbledore, the beloved headmaster and greatest wizard of all, is dead, killed by the master everyone hates, Severus Snape. Hogwarts is in the hands of the enemy, and is certainly no place for Harry Potter and his two closest friends, Ron Weasley, the redheaded good bloke, and the frizzy-haired clever-clogs of Muggle parentage, Hermione Granger.
In the seventh and final volume, Rowling left herself a formidable array of narrative challenges. She had to tie up the innumerable loose ends, every one of which is about as safe to touch as a live electric wire. And she had to complete a readable narrative in which – surely to goodness (literally) – Voldemort would get his comeuppance.
The problem for her was that, in narrative terms, she had reached the stage where all that was required was a denouement, and an explanation. And yet how could she write a book that was, in effect, “all” explanation of the mysteries that had gone before; and one that by definition (since Hogwarts was out of bounds for Harry and chums) could no longer follow the comforting old course of the school-story conventions, with its reassuring interludes of common-room gossip, of lessons with wildly eccentric teachers, Quidditch matches and food, glorious food? The answer is that nobody else could have pulled off such a narrative feat without being a bit heavy. Rowling does not disappoint us, though. Addicts will remember from the end of the sixth book that Dumbledore charged Harry with the discovery of the various Horcruxes into which Voldemort had cunningly divided his soul or personality to avoid death.
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows duly follows the shape of a classic quest-romance, with many of the traditional hazards encountered along the way. (When, for example, Harry needs to get into the Lestrange Vaults in Gringotts Bank, to retrieve a Horcrux, he sure enough finds a dragon guarding the treasure, and there is a satisfying escape from Death Eaters when the three friends, Ron, Hermione and Harry, fly away on the back of this dangerous creature.)
Rowling makes appetising side dishes out of overlooked scraps – Griphook, for example, the disagreeable goblin first met when Harry, aged 11, draws out some of his gold galleons from Gringotts, turns out in this final book not merely to have his heroic side, but also to remind the children (children! They are now 17!) of the by no means innocent magical historical past, and of the injustices done in days gone by to goblins and elves by wizards. Another good thing in this book is the extent to which even our, and Harry’s hero-worship of Dumbledore is tested. The history of Dumbledore, his relentless ambition as a young man, his neglect of his family, and the risks he has taken in withholding information from Harry during the previous six books are all rightly held up to critical scrutiny, even if Rita Skeeter's “expose” of The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore is the garish and inaccurate farrago we should expect. The duel that took place between Dumbledore and Grindelwald in 1945 (significant date, surely?) was not a straight conflict between good and evil. There was impurity in Dumbledore’s quest for power over a rival wizard.
Some of you will not yet have read this book, so I cannot spoil the story for you. It is of course unbearably dark. Hedwig the owl is killed in the opening scenes, as Harry makes his final exit from 4 Privet Drive, and from then on, we know that the curses of the Death Eaters will fall with the merciless success of Homeric arrows at the height of battle in the Iliad. To those of you who loved Dobby the house elf, or the werewolf Lupin, and Tonks (by now married with a baby), I give nothing away, but keep the Kleenex close. There is one twist of the “surprise” plot, however, which I must disclose since it is key to the whole oeuvre. (Turn away now if you don’t want to know it.) Harry has been wrong all along about Severus Snape. The greasy-haired potions teacher and giver of detentions has, since childhood, adored Harry’s mother, Lily Evans. Since her death, Snape has been a tirelessly courageous double agent, so good at his work that he hoodwinks the Dark Lord up to, and beyond the moment of his own heroic death.
What is the story all about, in the end? Love and death. Tom Riddle, who transmutes himself into Voldemort, wants power over death. But so, too, did Dumbledore – that is the point of the three Hallows, magical devices: a wand, an invisibility cloak and a “resurrection stone” that parallel Riddle’s Horcruxes. In wizard lore they first appear in the nursery story of The Tale of the Three Brothers. The first two brothers try to trick death, and come to sticky ends playing tricks with the resurrection stone and the wand. The third, who remained hidden in the invisibility cloak until he was old and ready to die anyway has learnt to greet Death as an old friend.
The story hedges its bets about whether life after death is “true” or whether Harry’s conversations with the dead Dumbledore, or his dead parents, are just happening inside his head. “Of course it is happening inside your head, Harry, but why on earth should that mean that it is not real?”
What these books ultimately hinge upon, however, is an unshakeable belief that love is stronger than death, and that while the pursuit of power is illusory, the pursuit of love will always in some way be rewarded.
It would be easy to write a sermon that spelt out such familiar ideas. But there are not many writers who have JK’s Dickensian ability to make us turn the pages, to weep – openly, with tears splashing – and a few pages later to laugh, at invariably good jokes. The sneerers who hate Harry Potter, or consider themselves superior to these books often seem to be hating their harmlessness – the fact that they celebrate happy middle-class family life, and the adventures of children privileged enough to attend a boarding school. But, as WH Auden said in another context, why spit on your luck? We have lived through a decade in which we have followed the publication of the liveliest, funniest, scariest and most moving children’s stories ever written. Thank you, JK Rowling.
HARRY POTTER AND THE DEATHLY HALLOWS
Bloomsbury £15.99 pp608
Buy the book here
at the offer price of £15.99 (inc p&p)
Read on...
websites: www.jkrowling.com
Rowling’s official website
How the new breed of location based mobile services can find your nearest cashpoint, restaurant or wi-fi hotspot
Enjoy screenings of all the classic films you love, plus take advantage of two-for-one tickets
We explore leisure activities that are safe and suitable for all of the family
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Are you California dreaming? Explore the wonders of the Golden State. Also enter our fantastic competition
See the best entries in this year's competition
Your brain is capable of more than you might think...
An interactive preview of the brand new For Your Eyes Only exhibition
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers

Love Sudoku? Play our brand new interactive game: with added functionality and daily prizes

Are you irritable when you return from work? Drained of emotion? You could be suffering from boreout
Prepare for some shock and awe, petrol lovers. Despite the greens trying to wipe it out, the car is about to offer us the most exciting year ever
We've trawled the brochures and websites to find this summer’s best holidays for every taste and budget

Pick up new releases when you buy The Times or The Sunday Times
2006
£189,500
NW England
2008/08
£169,950
NW England
2007/57
£35,000
South East England
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £82,000 per annum
Birmingham Women's Hospital
Birmingham
To £28k
Barclaycard
Various (outside London)
£
Up to £66,000 per annum
Hertfordshire County Council
South East
To £38k
Barclaycard
Northampton/Liverpool
2 Bathrooms, Balcony and Garden
Beautiful Gardens w/ stunning Thames Views
Dining, Shopping & Riverside Pk
Mortgages, bank acc & money transfers to help you buy abroad
Explore mystical Jordan
From £1030 for 7nts 4*
to USA's Most Cosmopolitan City; San Francisco!
£POA
Book Now for Winter 08/09 and Get 10% off!
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Search globrix.com to buy or rent UK property.
© Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
The spoilers are not even critically analysed. They seem gratuitous and are grating. Of course I read the book first; I knew you would give away juicey bits. Why don't you read some other reviewers and find out how they do it?
solana, dublin,
Is everyone reading the same review???Why does A N Wilson give away the twist about Snape, that wasn't revealed until the final few pages of the book? This was a fantastic piece of writing by JK Rowling, which is more than can be said for this review. A good review should ultimately entice the reader into reading the book, if it is merited, which Wilson makes clear that it is. However, to give away the highlight of the plot, smacks of a reviewer who is too lazy or unskilled to communicate, whilst still keeping this under wraps. In answer to other comments, I'd read a review before the book, to help me decide on whether to commit to read it or not. Why would I read a review after reading the book - who cares then? I'll have my own opinion. Very disappointed & certainly won't seek the opinion of A N Wilson in the future
Al, Warwickshire, UK
As I sit here all I can think is how lucky am I? I was read the first Potter novel by my mum, as a bedtime epic. Growing older I would sit in the garden with my friends devouring page after page of the latest installement and now, one year younger than Harry is in the seventh book, the words of J.K Rowling still continue to entrance and ensnare me as they always have. How one women can captivate millions is iincredible. Thank you so much for provididng us all with an imaginative world in which we can slip in and out of, a place where we have lived out a huge proportion of our childhoods.
Bella, Manchester, UK
Very good review indeed. Once Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows came out, I refused to read any reviews until I had finished reading the book myself. I did not want any accidental revelations to spoil my enjoyment. The only point that's missing in the review is the obvious parallel between Harry and Jesus. Harry is willing to sacrifice himself for the "Greater Good" of not just the wizarding community but all of mankind and then, of course, he "resurrects" and comes back for the final showdown or "judgement day".
Maja Sirola, Munich, Germany
Best review I've read. I started reading the books in my early 30s and I thank the reviewer for not looking down on us adults who found the books to be great storytelling. For those who complain about spoilers, why on earth would anyone read a review if they haven't read the book? It's impossible to discuss any book without talking about the plot.
Alka, London, UK
I agree this is the most thorough and intelligent review I've read of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. Bravo! Easily as good as anything in publications such as the New York Times Book Review, which rarely touches upon the Potter books. It even provides historical context, such as the point about the excitement that surrounded the end of the Old Curiosity Shop! Or the point about the Dumbledore/Grindelwald battle in 1945. I also agree I wouldn't have wanted to read it before reading the book, so perhaps there should have been a clearer warning to fans. But the reason this review is so good is because its not crippled by a fear of "spoilers." Who can discuss a work intelligently without referring to the details of character and plot?
Kevin, Buffalo, USA
This is the best review I've read of the book so far, thanks for writing it. It really gets to the heart of why people love Harry Potter so much.
gwen, Charlottesville, VA, USA
There were far too many spoilers in that review, and even one would have been too many.
Why on earth did you not head the column with a warning about spoilers, which many web sites do.
I have already read the book, but there are many adults, who would have enjoyed the book over the next few weeks whose pleasure has been reduced by this review.
Alice Dain, ware, Herts
I started reading Harry Potter when I was 11 years old and now almost seven years later I finished the seventh book. Harry changed like as, not only the enviroment wich surrounds him but also himself in body and soul. It might seem unimportant for grown ups up but for us, my own generation he is one of us, he grew just like all of us. His fears of failing on his mission, of choosing a career are part of our daily life. Harry was a young kid and now I imagine him of my own age, he went with me all my highschool... there was always another year left at school, and always another Harry Potter book to wait for. Now has ended... Harry fulfill his mission,,, we finish school and it is over, a part of my childhood went with him, as I finished reading the seventh book I couldnt help myself and cried...not only because all the deaths but mostly for all the years that passed away and will never return thank you rowling for giving us Harry who will always remind us of our childhood
Florencia, Buenos Aires , Argentina