Saw the show at Wembley last night and it was magnificent. Dylan must have taken notice of what David Sinclair said about last weeks show; he and his backing group didn't "lounge around", he didn't "lean over the microphone", his voice wasn't "creaky and quavering", he didn't "mangle" the lyrics, he didn't offer "little variation in his delivery", and he didn't give a "spluttering rendition of 'Like a Rolling Stone'".
Thank goodness there are such eminent music critics as Sinclair around, to knock the likes of Dylan into shape.
And to Gordon Mackett of Edingburgh: so are we mate.

Pete Breslin, Chertsey, England

I, being a long time fan agree that he should not have the number of concerts he is playing. Less is more. Will always go to see him in concert, and look forward to the new arrangements of his songs. Glasgow, the venue did not show him the respect he deserves Bob, how about smaller concerts. We would like a more intimate setting .
Love the radio show. What a fantastic gift for his devotees.

Dee, New York/New York, USA

As a fan of the great man for so many years it hurts me to say that he should give up the touring now, shows over the last few years have been frankly poor. Whoever you are you can go on for only so long without ending up disappointing those that have loved you so much - its not worth it, he should leave leave the touring there and us with our memories, glorious songs, wonderful albums and not forgetting some of the best bootlegs ever

Tony Ely,Welling,kent,UK

tony ely, welling,kent, UK

I love Dylan, have done since I was a 13 year old exposed to Freewheelin' but the 'Cult of Bob' which dare not see anything but majesty where there is ruin and 'Genius at its best' when from 'Time Out Of Mind to 'Modern Times' Dyaln has made three impressive records as the grand old man of rock, (or reinvented Bluesman if you must - first heard on 'Good as I been To You')
he hasn't come close to his first eight albums and the remarkable 'Blood On The Tracks' is just absurd, myopic, adolescent nonsense. Dylan hated the fans that made him The Voice Of A Generation' and I often wonder if today's concerts are his revenge. I still buy whatever he releases but I don't have to believe that silver is gold.

Kim Hatton, Nottingham, England UK

i was at the show and to say that bobby offered little variation from one song to another is absoloutly ludicrous and this guys supposed to be a music journalist. if you dont know what dylans about then why go and see him? i think that its the best part of seeing him live.
he very rarely plays a song the same way twice and to hear the different renditions makes the concert. the majority of the crowd know the man they know his style and they get what they are expecting.A great show, there were a few outstanding songs on wednesday night such as "aint talking", "john brown" "its all right ma" "a hard rains a gonna fall" the mans a legend and i'll be there to see him every timehe's in scotland!

chris shannon, glasgow, scotland

I wasn't there, but I have an mp3 of It's Alright from that show and he was on fire.
I love the new arrangement. It was always a rock song at heart.
Man, this ageism with the critics really sucks. How fair is it to compare Rolling Stone with the 42 year old recording?
Also, Theme Time Radio Hour is a totally different thing from a Dylan show. If anyone expects on stage patter to resemble his radio show, then they should do their homework.

Bendik, New York, NewYork, USA

I loved it. Just the fact that he played guitar for four songs made it worthwhile. The "heavily disguised old favourites" mentioned in the article are what make his live shows great, he's a fantastic arranger/re-arranger of music, just listen to his "At Budokan" album for proof of this. If you want to hear the songs done the same old way, time after time, stay at home and listen to his studio albums.

Shane Percival, Edinburgh, Scotland

glad we did not go

gordon mackett, edinburgh, uk

I think I must have gone to a different concert. Dylan was magnetic,his voice was better than in many years and his phrasing,particularly on It's All Right Ma.....I'm only bleeding was, with its articulation,bullet perfect.
The Band could have been tighter but Bob Dylan was as tight as a fist...............diving into a back catalogue over 47 years he gave us final proof of two things........when he wants to be....and right about now he does,there is no other Performing Artist that can hold a candle to his Sun......and he fully proved that the young man of 17 who wrote in his School Year Book....'To Join L:ittle Richard'....did that and oh so much more.

James Gilpin, Dumfries, Scotland