I saw the Brighton gig and thought that Scott's vocals lacked any depth, in fact you could hear Matt and Duffs backing vocals over his quite often. At one stage I thought a sound man was controlling his mic as more then once his mouth was moving but you couldn't hear anything. I thought as a gig it was fairly poor, although the GNR numbers stuck out, and Fall to Pieces was epic and seeing Matt, Duff in Slash in your home town was pretty special.. Not the chattiest band you'll ever see.

Tim, Brighton,

I think that velvet revolver have some of the best chemistry from the start and libertad there new album shows there great talent of writing music with each other I think it would be a really massive shame if they split up so if they read this i really hope you dont split

henry , oxted, england

I saw Velvet Revolver in the Brighton centre on the 26th March and i thought they were nothing short of incredible. I went in with no previous knowledge of them and left deaf and happy. Superb.

karl, brighton,

i saw them at at birminingham on the 23 and thought they were amazing every think was brill they played for at least 2 hours and every song rocked the crowd went mad just like they should when a graet rock band are playing ive seen them twice be fore and this was by far the best ive seen them im not a big fan of scott but he did sing great and the rest of the guys just did what they do best look good and rock with the best of them they are the best band around at the moment and no other comes close

mark, worcester, england

I saw Velver Revolver on 26 March at Brixton, and quite frankly, it was the worst performance from a major rock act that I have ever seen. In fact, it was the only rock show ever I have left well before encores because it was so bad. For the record, I was a music writer 1986-96 and interviewed both Slash (95) and Duff (91).

Kulta Turbo Platina, London, UK

I was at the Birmingham gig (Carling Academy - terrible venue - unless you get there early you can't see anything). The band played with professionalism, but only Scott Weiland seemed to put any real effort into the show. He's a great frontman, and he really engaged with the audience, who loved him. They also loved Slash, but I think more because of his iconic status than his playing. The solos are boring and unimaginative, and he appears to have lost his creative steam.

They also went on too long, and I left just before the end, having seen enough. They are the rock version of a football team struggling to avoid relegation from the Premier League.

Steve, Warwick,

I've been in both dates @ Carling Academy Brixton...
The show was amazing.To be honest I don't like Scott as a singer but I have to admit that he is a brilliant performer.
And comments like "the worst band I have ever heard" don't even have any connection with the reality.
The sound was better on the second day.
These band is the only good thing that happened to rock n roll for this decade.
Slash,Duff and Matt still rock and they are tight and play better more than ever.

argyris, LONDON, U.K.

I saw velvet revolver at brixton tuesday 25th March 2008. They were without exception the worst rock band I have ever heard, sorry heard, I mean endured. Weiland is incredibly overrated and not even a match for the much maligned Rob Halford, in fact halford would have worked bettter. The only class element was slash but so cliched now is his stance and style that even seeing for the fist time an axe demi God did not tempt me to stay. Go back home and dis-band for the love of rock..PLEASE

tAILOR, SOUTHEND,

In a word - amazing

Helen Gossling, Bournemouth, England