Truly brilliant, awesome and mesmerizing.

Ken, london, uk

25/6/08: from where i was, central,between the stage and the mixing desk, the sound, light show, performance, set list, atmosphere, interaction was spot on. exactly what i wanted to see and hear, great gig, thanks. anyone know the stuff that was coming over the PA pre-show ?

phil T, swansea, wales

I know people wanted to see more of the "hits" but that just seems quite a fan-boy remark to me. It was the In Rainbows tour so they were bound to play a lot of tracks off that. I think another reason for that set list would come down to the mood of the day and evening.

Harry, York, England

The only reason they sold the 40-50K tickets was on the strength of the mid-90s albums and they should have been more heavily featured. Pre-encore very few people around me even bothered to applaud. If they're not careful, all they'll soon have left will be their hard core fans. Nice food though.

Gary, Chelmsford, UK

There seem to be two types of Radiohead fan. Those that love their early stuff and dislike or even resent their later work, and those that love Radiohead pre and post-KidA. People in the 1st group need to recognise that Radiohead are constantly evolving. No LP is regurgitated because it worked.

Marios, London, UK

I thought the set list nigh on perfect, from Just, Planet Telex, through Airbag and The Tourist and into the Kid A/Amnesiac material (the best of the night (IMHO) and of course the sublime In Rainbows stuff.
Would have loved them to play more but as Thom put it "pumkin time was 10:30".

John, Luton, UK

A massive "fan" of Radiohead I was - it would seem. The music is still fantastically constructed, and the sound is awesome, but from where I was standing (about 2/3 back), it did not work. The crowd were not smiling or dancing - more looking around in bewilderment. Why not play some more classics?

Graeme , London, England

Terrible self indulgent nonsense from start to finish. One of the worst gigs I've ever seen by a bunch of over hyped middle aged sixth formers. And what were the "ethics behind the gig" Claire? Didn't you see strewn garbage over the roads leading from park to tube stops? Way to save the planet!

Graham, Chippenham, England

'Avant garde meets the masses...'

Michel, London,

If you would rather they had played Creep than Pyramid Song then your clearly not a real fan of Radiohead. This gig was absolutely mesmerizing form start to finish! If you want dated predictable "Hits", stay at home and listen to the fake "best" of released by EMI. Thats not what Radiohead are about

Joe, London,

It was amazing - but it was 20-odd bits of amazing stuck together rather than a whole. Didn't have a problem with the setlist per se - anyone expecting lots of early stuff hasn't really been paying attention for the last ten years - but it could have been structured a bit more strongly

Tom, London,

I was out about 10 rows deep. The reviewer did not notice the way people were moshing to Just. If they would have continued like that, it would have been difficult -they really controlled the crowd by putting up a "Peace and Happyness" song afterwards... Best performanec by a mile!

Spoos, Abingdon, UK

Incredible. And a gig for the fans in every sense. That's because the fans want to hear new material and new takes on old material and not just a load of tracks from the Bends which, lest we forget, is 13 years old.

Daniel, Croydon,

I felt very let down by this gig. Despite the perfect performance there was no engagement at all and this was entirely due to the dreadful setlist. Dullars and Cents? Cymbal Rush as a second encore?

I've rarely felt so disappointed. Would the band play this set at Glastonbury? Nope.

Martyn, Poole,

The was some amazing music being played last night. A fantastic set and a performance including a brilliant rendition of 'Banger and mash'. Yes it lacked some of their big anthems but their music is so much more than that.

Rob, Colchester,

I'm amazed that even now I can feel let down by Radiohead when they produce something new. I feel that they have lost sight of what makes us tick....and then with each listen the music hooks.

Last night I left feeling empty from the experience and today 'In Rainbows' sounds a little different.

Phil, London, UK

Was a bit disapointed at the play list as Creep or Fade Out were not included, but still an awesome set and the ethics behind the gig were enough in themselves to blow you away!

Claire, London, England

The success of last night, lies with the skill to control, move, manipulate an audience of this scale so vastly.
I was there. I "mosshed" for my life to "Just" and hypnotized and paranoid by "Climbing Up The Walls." If you want Karaoke go to your local. I want to experience music being made.

Nick Meadows, London, UK

Clearly not a fan-- I've seen them & it blew my mind-- their music craft is 2nd to none.I don't want to be chatted at by Thom; I don't need to feel I like the guy(s) to like their music.Discordant-- you're way off-- they were tight in every sense bringing their impossible recorded music to the stage

Mitch Ward, Chester, England

yes ok , but what of the venue ?? was it well organized ? a good spot?? what time did they go on?? how long they play for ?? was there anyone else there apart from the reviewer ?? come on ??

paul, london, london

As a fan of Radiohead both past and present, it was odd to feel so detached. The sonic scope & musicality was stunning, but a lack of engagement left me feeling cold. Setlist was poorly structured & too self-indulgent for a gig this size, & ignoring all the 'hits' appeared somewhat petulant. A pity.

KF, London,