Adam Sherwin, Media Correspondent
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes
The Commission for Racial Equality commended Channel 4 yesterday for the swift removal of a Big Brother contestant who used a racially offensive term.
Emily Parr, 19, from Bristol, called Charley Uchea, a fellow housemate, a “nigger” during a misguided attempt to adopt urban “street” language.
Producers, under scrutiny after Ofcom’s damning verdict over the Celebrity Big Brother racism row, removed Ms Parr within hours of the word being uttered, and said that such behaviour would not be tolerated. Tonight’s eviction vote, for which Parr had been nominated, has been suspended.
Ms Parr, a middle-class drama student, was heard to say: “Are you pushing it out, you nigger?” to Ms Uchea while they were dancing in the living room. Ms Uchea and other housemates expressed shock. Ms Parr said that she had not intended to be offensive and said the term was exchanged widely during discussions with her black friends.
Channel 4 bosses were alerted to the exchange, which was removed from the E4 channel “as-live” feed. Criticised for failing to act against the alleged bullying of Shilpa Shetty during Celebrity Big Brother, this time the response was swift.
Ms Parr was called to the diary room at 3.30am yesterday and told that she being was removed from the house immediately without further contact with other contestants. The channel is offering refunds to viewers who had voted to evict Ms Parr. A show spokeswoman said that it had closed the phone lines as soon as it could.
Angela Jain, the Big Brother commissioning editor, said: “We must consider the potential offence to viewers regardless of Emily’s intentions and her housemates’ response. The word is clearly racially offensive and there was no justification for its use. We have removed Emily to make it clear that such behaviour won’t be tolerated.”
A spokesman for the Commission for Racial Equality said: “While racism is in the ear of the beholder, this word is clearly offensive. We’re relieved that Channel 4 acted quickly.”
The housemates have signed up to rules that make clear they will be removed if their behaviour causes serious offence to viewers or contestants. Channel 4 believed that it was appropriate to screen the incident in last night’s edited highlights show. The word was “bleeped” after its first full utterance.
Ms Parr, who describes herself as right-wing, said that another housemate had previously used the offending word. Channel 4 said it had found no evidence of that.
Hertfordshire police, which has a unit to monitor the show, filmed in Elstree, received no complaints. Tony Blair’s spokesman said: “We deplore anything that could be perceived as racist.” The Tories praised Channel 4 for its quick action.
What she said
Emily: (referring to Charley’s hips) You pushing it out, you n*****?
Nicky: (shocked laughter) I can’t believe you said that.
Charley: You are in trouble.
Emily: I was joking.
Charley: I know you were . . . but that’s some serious s**t.
Emily: Why?
Charley: Maybe you see it in a rap. Maybe you and your friends sit there saying it.
Emily: I’m friendly with plenty of black people.
Nicky: You call them n*****s?
Emily: Yeah, and they call me n*****s. They call me wiggers as well.
Nicky: I’m quite shocked.
Emily: It’s not a big deal though, is it?
Charley: Not for us it ain’t.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
. The word she used..clearly upset Charley. Good call big brother, its time to make a stand on ALL types of racism. Are we forgetting where that word actually came from and what is was used for?
A, Bexhill,
A: cite your evidence for claiming that Charley was "clearly upset". I point you to the fact that she repeatedly said "no, I'm not offended" and "no, I'm not upset at all" when the other contestant was repeatedly telling her she was. She was upset about the possibility of Emily being evicted - read the full transcript.
As for remembering where the word came from: are you aware of the origins of all the words that we speak? Do you have any idea how many every day words have some pretty dark pasts? We're not all offended by them, why choose to be offended by this when she was so obbiously paroding black culture, no different to a Little Britain sketch?
Laura Roberts, London, UK
Emily knew the rules about racism, she has no ecxuse for what she said to charley.
Big Brother acted swiftly and were quite right in what they did.
This country should not tolerate this type of language.
Well done Big Brother.
paul brigden, birmingham, england
well I don't think she meant anything by it, and by the context it was used in, think they should have made the public decide wether to keep her in or not...
As a black woman, I hate the N word now, but grew up where it was okay for our white friends to use that word...it was never said in a way to voilate, more just slang useage....think the producers went OTT
shereen, London, England
If there is one thing more annoying than PC, its APC. Yes anti-political correctness. It is never acceptable to use such words that were created to offend. No White person should say these words. Ok banning ba ba Black sheep is one thing, but saying disgusting words that this pathetic housemate used are Never acceptaple. It wouldn't matter to me if 10 million people were on her side, Their wrong. I was fed up of Political Correctness but am much more fed up with Anti-Political Correctness, which only allows ignorant people to sound reasonable, which belive me they are Not.
William O'Reilly, London,
Far too much deference is given to the "sensitivity" of ethnic minorities to the use of certain words or phrases. This is then used as a stick to beat the mainstream society with which far too many of them fail to satisfactorily integrate, although they're poised to respond instantly and loudly to any imagined slur. As far as I'm concerned, if it's OK for black people to call each other nigger, then it's fine for everyone else, too - one crucial measure of integration is parity in speech, conduct, etc., not privilege.
David Russell, Sheffield, South Yorkshire
Watch the video. That transcript is incomplete. The black girl called herself the n world quite a few times in the middle of that exchange.
Andrew, Jacksonville, Florida, USA
Anyone that wastes their time watching this kind of crap must be daft anyway so who cares? It's not like anyone with half a brain is going to see it.
Dave_D, Morehead, NC/USA
Iam sick of these racial lessions created by the media .
The way these stage managed ethnic events appear is as predictable as the media orchestrated reaction.
tim, dorchester, uk
It is normal for people who have afro-caribbean friends to use this word jokingly, it is only the over sensitive ones that have issues with this or a minority of black people who have no contact with white people who might not understand this.
John, London, UK
There's no excuse. Its a clear case of casual racism. Maybe she is used to saying it around her friends, but would she have used the term to one of the other housemates? I think not. The word she used was completely unecessary and clearly upset Charley. Good call big brother, its time to make a stand on ALL types of racism. Are we forgetting where that word actually came from and what is was used for?
A, Bexhill,
In my opinion a drastic action, a warning might have been better, Suppressing ones opinion and punishing one is not the right way, whole thing is getting out of proportion. We live in a democratic country and free speech and opinion is one of them.
Munna, London, UK.
If BB wants to take the moral highground, why are they still protecting the Celeb BB protagonists by not publishing all the footage.
This was a sustained attack, rather than a stupid off hand comment.
Simon , London,
Why can an “African American” like Chris Rock use this term to describe another “African American” but a white person can not?
We have become too sensitive due to liberal who push civil and human rights.
Learn to get over it and concentrate on more important issues.
For this honky, pomey, gai jin it is not an important issue.
David, riyadh, saudi arabia
disproportionate response - silly girl - but a warning might have been better, fact would not have happened if C4 was not subject to its own pressure from the previous series. That said the contenstant were also aware of the previous events in BB. Might have been better for BB to raise the matter for discussion between the house mates to consider the correct punishment
Stephen Mark Wood, Leeds, UK
I found what emily said very offensive.. not to say very rude im a mixed race wowan and i would never call anyone of any colour a racially.abusive word..........
tasha, Leytonstone, london
I personally feel Big Brother / Channel 4 have seriously neglected the needs of a young and naive 19 year old girl. Fair enough she made a harmful and very offensive comment but I hand on heart dont believe she really knew what she was saying every single person out there has said something at one time or another in the heat of the moment without thinking and without prejudice.
This poor girls life has been seriously affected by this comment, her safety and the safety of her family for years to come may be at risk and Big Brother / Channel 4 are to blame for whatever may occur.
The media attention towards this has added hype and viewing figures, possibly adding more fuel to the fire! Is this a question of ratings?
Fair enough a serious and hard hitting stance was needed, although I personally feel that this girl was not aware of her surroundings, she felt comfortable and at ease with her peers forgetting about the cameras.
David, N Ireland, UK
yes i totaly agree that emily should be evicted as that n word has been banned and not used anymore for many years
tanya, western supermare, somerset
It's just a good example of why Big Brother doesn't work as a concept!
I personally don't use the word and I could understand why it would offend somebody but the programme is simply not in the real world!!
A bit harsh for a comment that was not really thought out? Perhaps each member should have their own press secretary??
Nevermind I suppose the ratings went up a bit?
N, Scotland,
Emily, is ignorant and to say in the diary room '' I'm not the only one that has said it'' shows this clearly. Just because some else allegedly used an offensive term did not give her the green light to use it as well.
She did not understand the impact of what she had said, and the fact she even uses words like this shows she uses it as part of her everyday vocabulary.
Well done Ch 4 for dealing with this in the manner on which you did.
Anita Dabasia, London,
Controvesy over morals?
Channel 4 must have captured many racist comments and incidents over the years of Big Brother. They have been rightly criticised for the behaviour that they have turned a blind eye to for so long.
They must have been rubbing their hands with glee as a 19 Yr old girl makes an inappropriate remark and becomes one of the most convenient "whipping boys" in modern T.V history.
Are channel 4 now acting as acurate barometers into the moral code of the U.K?
On Tuesday evening they showed footage of the one male housemate that they have allowed into the house, being chased by female housemates who were making an active effort to strip him of his clothes. How would this footage have been percieved if the genders were the other way round?
Can channel 4 seriously encourage and yet condone racism by their actions and perhaps do the same thing with sexual assault. Maybe it makes good T.V. either way?
Rob Oldcorn, Coventry,
This is completely and utterly ridiculous. I can't even bring myself to explain why, because to any half-wit with even a tenuous understanding of context can see why it wasn't offensive.
Charley (half-wit would be a compliment for that girl) is a desperate attention seeking media whore, who knew full well what she was doing by repeating what happened over and over again. It was in no way a shocking comment to make.
Pathetic. Utterly pathetic.
Nisha, Leicester,
im a black person and i dont thik emily really meant it.she was taken out of context. The main reason why she was removed was because of he pressure of the viewers.
mohammed, cambridge,
I think it is going to far if an English person say anything racist then we get done but they can say anything they won't against us and they get away with it.
Ian Mosey, Doncaster, England
I think being P.C. has gone too far it seems to be ok to slag off white characteristics in humourous ways because it is perceived as just that i.e. someone who is ginger (referring to the nether regions) or someone who is blonde is considered as "dumb blonde". Every difference that is noticed in people can be used against them so why is something that wasn't used in an aggresive context be so appauling?
Karen, Central Region, UK
i think its a bit harsh to be fair, she obviously didnt mean any harm by it. but under the cirbumstances i do understand the big brother producers stance. after the last show they cant be seen to tolerate anything that could be taken as offensive. shame though.. terrible society we live in really. no sense of humour. PC culture bugs me
Bryan, Waterford,