A A Gill
Download 'Too Hot', an exclusive Specials track from iTunes

For all its right-here, right-now cool, I’m constantly amused by how obsessive-compulsive and geeky the new technology of omnipresent entertainment is. For instance, the iTunes system I’m listening to as I write this can’t help itself: it has to arrange all music into overlapping and interlocking lists, like some sad old vinyl-sniffing hippie. There are categories for every form of music: rock, classical, alternative, world and, bizarrely, French pop - a slim selection. And then, between “soundtrack” and “vocal”, there is a slot for “unclassifiable”, where even the might of the fathomless internet throws up its hands and gives in. I just looked into mine: it is a sad little musical refugee huddle of lost choirs. It’s all choral music - hymns, carols, plainsong liturgy, chants Gregorian and tribal. And I sort of know what the iTunes system means. There is something about choral singing that defies definition and description. The collective power of voices can physically tug the breath from your chest, cloud the eyes and put a lump the size of Gibraltar in your throat.
Or choral music can sound like Last Choir Standing (BBC1, Saturday). I have been orally immobilised by the breadth, invention and minutely crafted godawfulness of the arrangements, harmonics and twinkie descants in this spellbinding competition. What is so marvellously compelling is that there are quite so many teenagers and students out there who are publicly willing to give up any possible hope of a sex life or respect to live with the ridicule and revulsion of their peers, simply to take part in performing this wall of kitsch. What Strictly Come Dancing is to dancing, Last Choir Standing is to singing — and, indeed, standing.
The continuing story of a megalomaniac desperate to found a dynasty, whose paranoia turns a court and a family into a stew of fear, resentment, plots and suspicion: The Tudors (Friday, BBC2) are back for more. In my lifetime, Henry VIII has gone from being Keith Michell to Ray Winstone and now Jonathan Rhys Meyers, proving history is pretty much whatever you need it to be. The story of Henry’s profligate misuse of wives was once all about heredity; now it’s all about sex. The Tudors have gone from Burke’s Peerage to Mills & Boon, and Rhys Meyers is definitely the chick-hist choice. Personally, I find him hard to believe as a renaissance prince, creator of a new religion and the man who oversaw the greatest metamorphosis in the social, political and cultural life of a nation, dragging England out of the Middle Ages into the light of reason. In fact, despite the amount of swyving he does, I have trouble seeing him as a heterosexual: there’s just too much smouldering, pouting and peck-flexing for him to be straight. It’s all trying too hard, and he's too camp. But there’s a bigger character problem for The Tudors, possibly the biggest character problem known to historical drama, a catastrophic part malfunction: Sam Neill.
I assume Neill is in this thing because his agent has photographs of the producers in a safe, or perhaps because Americans want to see at least one face they recognise. Neill’s presence makes this Tudorassic Park. Now, I have a large and squidgy soft spot for him: he is about as far away from being an actor as it’s possible to be and appear on screen at the same time. He has really only one expression, a look of worried incomprehension, as if his face were trying to fathom how on earth it managed to end up in front of a camera yet again. It’s a look he shares with his audience. Neill’s career arc is proof, not only that lightning can strike twice, but that it can strike repeatedly without ever illuminating anything. It was a pleasure to watch him stumble through the lines as if they were an Urdu shopping list, bereft of punctuation, and regard the rest of the cast with the groggy incomprehension of a man coming round from minor surgery in a room full of someone else’s relatives.
The enduring curse of the Tudors — and, indeed, quite a few of the Stuarts — is that, despite living in the most rollicking, murderous, passionate and attractive period in English history, their clothes were utterly naff and completely ridiculous. How on earth did those titans of testosterone and derring-do allow themselves to be kitted out in baggy nappies with willie pouches and tights, beanbag shoes, bolero jackets and Worzel Gummidge hats — or, worse, big dressing gowns with mad-granny jewellery? This production sensibly dispenses with any historical accuracy and kits out everybody like a cross between a Dutch brothel and Star Wars. In fact, to get the full benefit of The Tudors, don’t think of it as a historical costume drama at all, but as camp science fiction with a wooden dinosaur.
And now on to the continuing story of a megalomaniac desperate to found a dynasty, whose paranoia turns his court and family into a stew of resentment, plots and suspicion: Saddam Hussein’s rise to power in Iraq. The first thing you notice about House of Saddam (Wednesday, BBC2) is that it suffers the same style black hole as The Tudors. The Middle Eastern take on western clothes in the 1980s was really not a good look, a cross between Dynasty and Leeds United Football Club. This, though, is a good idea for a drama series: plenty of plot - and plots - lots of action and darkly Websterish motivation.
The first episode was as flat as a Hotel Babylon Christmas special. To begin with, there are no sympathetic characters. The writers have been unable to construct, invent or discover a nice Iraqi, and for the tension to work we have to like someone and care about them. But here, everybody is treated as a “towel-head”, drawn with the same broad and simplistic racial stereotyping. You don’t care who gets tortured and hanged next. Saddam himself is nothing like bad enough. He’s just not enough of a monster; he’s more annoying than bad. Like a bland and predictable shop manager, he had none of the saturnine steeliness, the creepy lizard charm, the sense of murderous danger and mad self-belief that were apparent in all the newsreels. This series yearns to be treated like a marriage between The Sopranos and I, Claudius, but there isn’t much suspense. We all know how this ends. Sadly, it simply confirms the Dick Cheney view of foreign relations and international drama.
Carol Vorderman has left Countdown, the relentlessly limp daytime game show that has been a dead format running for years. It has gone on, episode after episode, without ever raising the heartbeat or troubling the thoughts of suicide in the long-term unemployed, technically disabled and clinically depressed who were its core viewers. If you find yourself watching three episodes of Countdown in a row, it is medical proof that your life has actually, definitely, reached the bottom.
Vorderman slid numbers into a rack as a career; she was, to all intents and purposes, the knife-thrower’s assistant, but without the excitement, the dress sense or, sadly, the knives. Now she’s not going to do it any more, why does anybody care? Do I care? Do I look like I care? EFILATEG.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£24,250 - £30,346
MI5
London
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I followed both series of the Tudors so far and whilst it did seem like an attempt to make 16th century history like an American soap there was also a good deal of attention to detail with the Tudor court and the lead casting, with the exception of Jonathan Rhys Meyers himself ,was quite impressive
Stephen Charles Hopkins, London, UK
Interseting comments on Sam Neill's performance in Season 2 of the Tudors, especially since Neill's character was killed off at the end of the first series. Whatever his opinion of Neill as an actor, surely Gill should justify his considerable salary by actually watching the TV that he reviews?
James Wright, Guildford, United Kingdom
I first saw an advert for The Tudors when I was on holiday in America, their were also billboards everywhere. It was screened there before it even came to Britain. Totally made for the American market without a doubt.
Rebecca, Wetherby, UK
Why is AA Gill going on about Sam Neill? He wasn't even in it, his character, Wolsey, having died at the end of the first series. Did Gill even watch this week's episode? Carol Vordemann's real job in Countdown was to solve mathematical problems, she moved the cards about because she was there.
John Sims, Leiston, Suffolk, UK
How pop-hist dramas date! Look at "Catfart" or - better - the 1950's Robin Hood that still gets odd clips regurged. It's difficult looking coiffed and clean-shaven in the 21st century let alone being medievally challenged.
And Chewdahs don't need white-as-white linen to keep the advertisers happy.
Steve, Poole,
Tend to agree about Rhys Meyers but come on, the show is supposed to be glamorous and fun. Why worry about Sam Neill? His Wolsey part has already committed suicide. You may actually enjoy Peter O'Toole as The Pope in series two!
Geoff Paddock, Linslade, UK
"Rhys Meyers is definitely the chick-hist choice". Is this Gill being fantastically smart? Is he conveying the very essence of historo-comical tv drama? One can picture the scene instantly: a woman concealed behind a curtain attracts the passing king with a whispered "Hist".
Or is it a misprint?
Richard, London, UK
I think Molu's o.d.'d on Countdown.
Rupert Fotherington-Smythe, London, England
Didn't Sam Neil's character die in the last series?
I wasn't watching the episode very closely but I didn't notice him. You wouldn't have reviewed this without watching it, surely? Good job I never actually pay to read the Sunday Times, or I might demand my money back.
Stephen, Manchester,
I am trying to receive 2 tickets for the film preview miss pettigrew lives for a day in the west end and find that the offer is non functioning. Could you please enter me for this as stated on page 50 of the culture supplement, Thanks
maria schneider , richmond, surrey
well simply seeing tudors well aggrevaites what the viking was something to be recall as agreat stonehuinge ,., well seeing the kingdom epitah within the european wars ,. as that of sagas of huguenots ,. in quotas,,. one faith ,. one nations and one kings ,., and tudors being reduced as foe
molu , basel, switzerland
Sam Neil isn't in the second series. Has Mr Gill been give the wrong set of preview discs?
L Dunham, Malvern, UK
Forget history. Why don't producers find members of the public with great big egos and put them in a show where we can laugh at them and feel better about ourselves. Or, we could watch have-beens of yesteryear, cooking, being locked up in a house or in a quiz., as long as the questionhs are easy.
Bernard Lawson, London, England
Jonathan Rhys Meyers looks very annoying to me. I watched "Match point" last night - love Woody Allen, but that was absolute crap- and I added JRM to my list of "if he is in the movie I won't watch it", together with keira knightley, scarlett johansson, and a couple more I don't remember right now.
tete, buenos aires, argentina
Was AA Gill watching the same programme as me? Sam Neill died at the end of Series 1 - he certainly didn't feature in the first episode of this current series. Although a Violin did - a few decades too early I think but that's what makes this series so watchable!
Karen, Stanley, Derbyshire
The Tudors seem to have inherited Kirsty Wark's fashion advisor !
Winnie Bago, London ,
Oh please. "Der Chewdas" is just enormous fun, the best 9pm alternative to Big Brother there is on a Friday night! Like the Mamma Mia film - enjoy it for it is. Or turn off and go out. Or do a History degree with the OU.
Richard Flynn, Huntingdon, UK
Henry VIII did court Anne Boylen for years before they did get married. He was 32 when they first met, Anne was 16. She was about 29 when she was executed. I would have cast a red headed actor with gravitas. Catherine of Aragon was also red headed, so why is she always portrayed as dark haired?
M, Beds,
The other problem with Jonathan Rhys Meyers as Henry VIII is that he is too young - Henry was approaching 40 years old at the time the story is set.
Martin, Newmarket, Suffolk