Win VIP tickets

The judges on Britain's top TV talent shows are getting increasingly irritated by viewers who insist on phoning up and choosing the wrong winners.
So serious has the problem become that judges on Strictly Come Dancing appealed to viewers last night not to vote for the veteran BBC journalist John Sergeant, however much they may like him. "We're judging on the ability of dance," said the panellist Arlene Phillips. "It's very well that people fall in love with a man, but what his feet are doing isn't a foxtrot."
Both Strictly and its rival X Factor were hit by upsets this weekend as talented contestants were booted off before their time.
Sergeant, 64, and partner Kristina Rihanoff received just 12 points for their performance, which was not a foxtrot at all but a cha cha cha - although one judge joked that it was 'more Ha Ha Ha'.
But the housewives phoned in by the thousand to keep him in and in the end it was the former M People frontwoman Heather Small who was booted out after a dance-off with Rachel Stevens of S Club (7).
X Factor saw an even greater upset when the show lost Laura White, the 21-year-old Bolton songbird who had been tipped as a possible winner of the show.
White was voted off by judge Louis Walsh after a showdown with the Spaniard Ruth Lorenzo. Walsh's decision was seen as a tactical move to protect his boy band JLS and reportedly prompted a behind-the-scenes row with Cheryl Cole, who was mentoring the loser.
Cole, who found fame herself through Popstars: the Rivals, said that neither White nor Lorenzo should have been voted off. "The public has not been voting on talent, and that became clear tonight," she said on Saturday night's show. "I'm stunned both these girls were in the bottom two this week."
X Factor also has a housewives' favourite in Daniel Evans, the 38-year-old pool cleaner from Essex. In an uncharacteristically acute observation, Walsh told him he looked like "Ricky Gervais doing karaoke" but Evans had the female judges in tears when he dedicated a song to his late wife, who died last year after giving birth to a daughter.
Win a luxury weekend to Newcastle and its neighbour Gateshead, find out more here
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
Discover the power of collective thinking. Submit a solution and be in with a chance to win a Media Hub Home Entertainment System
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Make the most of the summer and enter our fabulous photographic competition, you could win a £5000 holiday
Corsica is an island of beauty and contrast, an ideal holiday destination
Enjoy further reading from Travel to Fashion, Business to Sport, discover more
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
The clever way to lease a new car is with Car leasing made simple™
2009
per month on 36-month
Personal Contract Hire (PCH)
2008
42850
Car Insurance
£23,093 - £56,211
The Office for National Statistics
Newport, South Wales
£60,000
The Environment Agency
Bristol
Up to £90K
Boots
Midlands
OTE £85k
Credit Protection Association
Nationwide Opportunities
Completely London
Luxury Condo's in Manhattan with NYC views
The best new homes in Wimbledon?
Nationwide
Fabulous Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers Including Virgin Atlantic Flights Prices Start From Only £699pp!
Last Minute Cruise And Cruise & Stay Offers. Med From £499pp, Caribbean From £699pp!
5 star quality at a 3 star price.
8 fabulous Canadian cities ...you won’t find cheaper
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions | E-paper
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2009 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Shame on the BBC for allowing such discrimination by the judges on SCD.JS has been harrased and bullied, not only abt his dancing but abt his age, and his weight. Also, they treat the public with contempt by suggesting that we don't know what we are doing when we vote for John.Sack them Beeb!
Doreen Harrison, Kidderminster, UK
When someone is invited to participate to a show, I never imagined it did include being insulted nor bullied. I would have loved to see more of him and carry on voting for him ...
I am just glad he left before he had a nervous breakdown.
Sorry for Kristina - a wonderful dancer . Nice holiday John
Mireille healy, Sutton, England
Claudia and the Gang of Four plus One have tried but failed to airbrush their parts in John's withdrawal. The profound level of insults and ageism (which is unlawful?) will hang in the air for time to come.
The sham is perpetuated by the the Sunday night show which seems to be prerecorded.
D, London,
John resigns and still the judges aren't happy. He obviously has more integrity than them and their hipocritical views. . I have supported John but it was the right time to go, before contestants who are desperate to stay blame him, or the wonderful Christina, for being knocked out. Thanks
Jules, Derby, UK
This can only happen in Britain - the least talented get the most votes. Grow Up
Hugo, Leighton Buzzard,
John Sergeant is the most entertaining out of all of them and THAT'S why i vote for him. Why was he invited in the first place? to be ridiculed? Judges need to get over themselves and RESPECT the public. It's called democracy and this is NOT a dance competition, It's entertainment!! John to win!!!
Chris, Preston, UK
To paraphrase comment by MGM executive on application by Fred Astaire to join company-
'Unattractive, balding, can dance a little'.
Prudence Eely Bond McGuire BA, LONDON, ENGLAND UK
Unfortunately these shows seem to be more and more about the judges and not about the contestants. Obviously the judges think it is a showcase for themselves. Perhaps there should be a phone vote on which of them goes??
Graham Lingley, Ipswich,
I have always loved and admired John Sergeant and was happy to see him in Strictly. However after his Paso Doble which was very funny, but turned him into a national joke, I think he should have retired gracefully. I now find his inept appearances in the show irritating. Sorry JS!
aline waites, London, UK
Whats this "housewife" term all about anyway? Its very irritating and suggests those women in the fifties who used to stay home and listen to Family Favourites and gas over the garden fence about Vince Hill. All ages watch SCD and all ages are voting for him (and Daniel from X Factor I may add).
Carolyn, London,
This is happening because men are sick and tired of all the prime time television being made for women. We pay the license fee too!
I'm voting for John Sergeant and Daniel from X-Factor as a form of protest and encourage others to do likewise.
Andrew, Fareham,
For goodness sake, its entertainment not the Olympics.
Robert, London,
I love watching John Sergeant and could not care less what the judges think. I will vote to see him each week as long as he is on the show.
MM
Ps How can Craig be taken seriously - have you seen that haircut!
Mary Morris, Glasgow, Scotland
I am appalled at the ageist comments and inequality from the judges. I'd like to see Len Goodman attempt a Latin American dance! They're not critiqueing John's performance, they're clearly biaised against him, and I don't like seeing a highly intelligent, mature gentleman treated so disrespectfull
Juliet Jarvis, Sanderstead,
A contestant only the public likes - yikes!
Esther, London,
History shows that throughout the ages,those that are entrusted with a vote, tend not to vote in accordance with the the implied wishes of the judges.Remember Barabbas?.
Mike , Peterborough, UK
Hey, isn't this show entertainment.
Surely the viewers are perfectly entitled to vote who they want to be entertained by.
jasper, chelmsford,
The public get what the public want!
Caroline , Barton, England
This is not the first time that an untalented but popular performer has outlasted better dancers/skaters/singers. If those who run the programme want to do away with the John Segeant syndrome then they will have to rethink the voting process and probably destroy the show.
Jill, Jersey, Channel Islands
This is not the first time that an untalented but popular performer has outlasted better dancers/skaters/singers. If those who run the programme want to do away with the John Segeant syndrome then they will have to rethink the voting process and probably destroy the show.
Jill, Jersey, Channel Islands
I'd like a vote on which of the judges should go. That would soon have them baying for public sympathy
Geoff Davies, Crewe, Cheshire
But Strictly Come Dancing is so much more fun when the judges are annoyed! And John's a poppet, isn't he? I'm NOT a housewife, by the way - I'm a twenty year old student!
Clare, Manchester,
The judges bring this upon themselves. Arlene drools over the athletes; Craig routinely bullies the easy targets, etc - then they have the gall to complain about subjectivity from others! John S wasn't very good, but some constructive comments and allowance for his age would not have gone amiss.
Austin, London,
best way to stop all yhe contraversy is to take both these terrible shows off the air and put something decent on
graham o'brien, bolton,
As for X Factor, if you ban peoples sob stroies from airing, then just base the airing on singing contest, then people will vote for singing. That is where X factor is going wrong, and it is their fault for airing these stories.
Tom, Chelmsford, UK
Look its bad enough I have to watch this show (my other half is addicted to it)but to see John every week dance like your dad at a wedding is killing me! I realise its a joke lets keep the silly old chap in but please its bad enough being tortured every week with out this.
simon, Bristol, England
why is anyone surprised?? The whole point of the show is to give the public the chance to say who they want to go through, that's democracy for you.... people don't always buy records based on talent, or vote governments in based on policy ;)
Ian, Newhaven, England
What evidence do you have that it is "housewives" who are voting for poor talent?
A Baillie, Pulborough, West Sussex
If you want to do well in the X-factor irrespective of talent. It is "essential" that you're male. You have to also be either young or have a nice smile. It also helps if you're Irish. The two weakest contestants are Daniel and Eoghan but unfortunately the public won't let them go easily.
Phil, Epsom, England
Pro-Bush paranoids dreamed up a press conspiracy, a liberal conspiracy, a socialist conspiracy, but they never thought of a housewives' conspiracy! Or maybe there's a conspiracy of ITV fans to sabotage a BBC show, and vice versa, by voting for bad acts? There's a (ratings) war on, remember.
joe, birmingham, uk
Hopefully...with a bit of luck..... this might be the beginning of the end for "talent" shows on the telly. We can only hope.
Pierre, Hemel Hempstead, Herts
The whole show is about charity, and making money for children in need. The more phone calls the more goes to charity. To vote John and his partner in every week means viewers are spending lots of money to keep him in. Sounds like a good scheme . The others will have to excel to keep their places.
Jimd, Norwich, Uk
The programme is too long now and lacks any tension. We are only now, after weeks of this, beginning to get down to the people who are competative. John has provided dignity ,spirit and a sense of fun which has been lacking so far. He has deserved his inclusion.
Delfid, London,
Isn't democracy wonderful.
Akheloios, Wigan,
He might not have any talent, but he is entertaining. On X Factor, Mariah Carey or rachel should have been voted off, the former was dreadful!
Mike, Gloucester, uk