Mark Franchetti, Moscow
Win a trip to the Ice Hotel in Lapland

WHEN Anya Kaluyeva, a Russian primary school teacher, was summoned to her boss’s office last week, she expected to discuss a new set of textbooks. The conversation quickly took a more sinister turn.
The head teacher asked the 48-year-old whom she intended to vote for in today’s parliamentary elections. When she hesitated, he ordered her to support United Russia, the party backed by President Vladimir Putin. He then issued a warning.
“He made it clear that if I didn’t vote for United Russia I’d lose my job,” said Kaluyeva, a mother of two who lives in a small town south of Moscow.
“I was so shocked I was left speechless. He put me under pressure and hinted that he had ways of checking who I’d voted for. I felt I was back in the Soviet Union.”

As millions of Russians go to the polls to vote for a new Duma, the 450-seat lower house of parliament, the result is a foregone conclusion. United Russia will win by a landslide. The vote, however, is much more than an ordinary parliamentary election.
Putin, who is due to step down in the spring when his second and final term permitted by the constitution ends, has turned the poll into an unofficial referendum on his eight years in power.
The Kremlin and the Russian president are thought to believe that anything less than 65% in favour of United Russia would be regarded as a failure.
There has been mounting evidence that voters have come under intense pressure to vote for United Russia. State employees ranging from teachers to doctors and factory workers have been ordered to cast their ballot for Putin and United Russia or face reprisals, including dismissal or demotion.
University students have accused professors of threatening them with expulsion or poor marks unless they vote for the Kremlin’s favoured party.
Some students have been told to vote at polling stations on campus, supervised by a lecturer, while others have been led to believe that hidden cameras have been installed in polling booths.
Workers at one factory in the Urals have claimed that their boss ordered them to take a photograph of their ballot paper with their mobile phone to prove they voted for United Russia.
At another state enterprise, in Siberia, the management received a letter from the local branch of United Russia warning that the Kremlin had been informed of its refusal to contribute funds to the party’s election campaign. “Your refusal has been taken as a direct rejection of Putin and his course,” it read.
A Moscow doctor, who was too scared to give his name, said the director of his clinic had told staff to vote for United Russia or their state funding would cease.
Critics say the pressure on voters to support the Kremlin’s choice and the relentless pro-Putin propaganda are reminiscent of Soviet times. Russia’s postelection political landscape is also likely to resemble the days of the cold war when the country voted for only the Communists.
According to the latest polls, United Russia will win more than two-thirds of the vote. The Communists are the only other party sure to pass the 7% threshold needed to win a parliamentary seat.
“We are witnessing the first absolutely nonfree election since the end of the Soviet Union,” said Vladimir Ryzhkov, an independent liberal MP and Putin critic who has been barred from standing again.
Opposition parties have accused authorities of confiscating campaign materials and said managers of halls have refused to rent them out for meetings.
Sergei Mitrokhin, a leader of the liberal opposition party Yabloko, said today’s elections would be “the dirtiest in Russian history”. Yesterday Yabloko’s website was crippled by hackers shortly after it posted a video critical of Putin.
Foreign observers have decided to boycott the poll in protest at extended visa delays.
State television channels make no attempt to be balanced in their coverage. Cities across the country are plastered with giant billboards bearing the slogan: “Putin’s victory is Russia’s victory.” In the kind of sycophantic coverage once reserved for polit-buro chairmen, national state TV channels religiously open the evening news with glowing reports on Putin.
A speech that Putin gave last week, in which he accused the West of seeking to disrupt the elections and described opposition politicians as “foreign-backed jackals”, led the evening news, in a 16-minute report.
Last Thursday the noon news programme on the country’s largest TV network led with a paid-for Putin address to the nation in which he called on voters to cast ballots for United Russia. It was repeated on other channels throughout the day, raising criticism that he was misusing state resources for open campaigning.
Tension is running high as all public opposition to Putin’s rule is being crushed. A week ago baton-wielding riot police beat up demonstrators and arrested Garry Kasparov, the chess grand-master turned fierce Kremlin critic, who heads a small, motley opposition group but is not standing in today’s poll.
The poll will determine what Putin does after the presidential elections in March. Barred by the constitution from serving more than two consecutive terms, the Russian president is due to step down.
Until only a few months ago Putin was adamant he would retire, but he recently indicated that he plans to use his popularity to influence Russian politics. The higher the number of votes for United Russia, now that he is at the top of its list, the greater Putin’s “moral authority”, as he put it, to stay on as “national leader”.
“We are only four months from presidential elections, and only one man in the whole of Russia has any idea of what will happen,” said Andrei Illarionov, a former economic adviser to Putin. “Putin’s regime resembles the mafia, and he behaves like its godfather.”
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
"Foreign observers have decided to boycott the poll in protest at extended visa delays".
Oh! What a tragedy! We won't sleep any more because of this fact!
Sophia, Moscow,
Putin is a dictator. He crushes all who stand in his way. Like Bush and then Blair about anyone who criticised the war in Iraq, they just assassinate the people who speak out. Free world, no we are all as bad as each other, the Russians are just not as skilled at it. ie. They have not had as much practice as the US and the UK and other freerer countries.
John Doe, Moscow, Russia
Well I must say he's paid attention to how his buddy W does things!
Harry Gatley, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
Dear President Putin
I'm pleased to learn that your Party, United Russia, has won by such an enormous margin. Rarely in the West has any single party been elected to governance with such a ringing endorsement from its electorate. A fact testified by our Labour Party and its control of our so called democracy, with less that 25 percent support from our electorate!
So bad have things become for our so called parliamentary democracy...(excuse me whilst I laugh loudly and prolonged)... it was murmered by a number of MP's that they were going to introduce laws to make it a criminal act not to vote!! How un-democratic is that!!!
Once again I congratulate the citizens of Russia in excercising their democratic convictions so clearly. Bravo to freedom :o)
David Downes, Chester, UK
The quicker the EU can get away from dependency on USSR for energy the better.
D Case, Newquay,
My wife is a lecturer at state university and my mother is a doctor at state clinic. No one has forced them and other my relatives to vote for Putin. That's true too.
Alexander, Saint Petersburg, Russia
As though the West was not afraid of Russia (in my opinion unjustly), but people has made the choice - bad it or good. And all this hysteria in foreign press in occasion of Putin's authoritarianism and usurpation of authority is far-fetched though to deny the fact general PR " Uniform Russia " there is no sense.
Roman, Moscow,
Russia has every right to view the West with contempt. They know democracy here is a myth, its just that they're not as sophisticated at faking it yet.
What is the difference between the Labour and Conservative party, pretty much nothing of substance. Therefore there is no political opposition. Its just a new set of faces, same agenda, the fraud continues. Business as usual.
Its as decadent as the blue/green rivalry of ancient Rome.
Keith Bentham, wigan, Lancashire
I guess ultimately there's no way to control how people actually vote. However, if the boss gets his staff to promise they vote United Russia, most people might do just that, if out of common decency only.
My brother, a municipal worker just north of Moscow, was told in no uncertain terms to join United Russia or lose his quarterly bonus. Having thus become a card-carrying member of the Poo Tin party, he was told to recruit ten more members.
In fact, the rot goes much further back, all the way to the 1996 presidential election brazenly stolen by Yeltsin and the 1993 "constitution" foisted on the country in a rigged referendum.
Anatoly, Moscow,
Marco:
I would remind you that whatever you think of the Bush presidency, the 2000 Florida vote numbers were pretty much confirmed by several post-election investigations, and GWB won the state by a tiny margin.
Its one thing to have confusion about reading a ballot and what constitutes a properly punched/filled out ticket in a state of 25 million people. Its another to tell someone to vote for a certain party or lose your job/education/benefits.
Steve, San Jose, California, USA
Odds on that all the UK's state apparatus employees and recipients of our beloved Labour government's benefits, tax credits etc will be subject to similar Putin-like pressure at the next general election.
That's democracy, as peddled by politicians today!
Tim Chappell, Gloucester, England
Exactly how can anyone verify who one votes for? I live in Russia and have been to the polls during elections. The voting is done in secret and on paper, not a touch screen. Has anyone given any thought to the fact that the Putin government has an 80+% approval rating from the general public? With a rating like that, is it that hard to believe Mr. Putin's party would get 60% or so of the vote?
James Leonard, Stavropol, RUssia
That's true.
In my university i, like a student, was forced to vote fot Putin, - the same situation with my relative, who works in Gazprom, - thats natural.
Kirill, Moscow, Russia