Hannah Strange
The man, the films, those blondes. Free DVD collection starting this Sunday
Hillary Clinton has been forced to retract a claim that she landed under sniper fire in Bosnia 12 years ago after a CBS video emerged contradicting her account, Hannah Strange writes.
The former First Lady was attacked by Barack Obama for exaggerating her role in foreign policy-making during her husband’s presidency, which she has frequently asserted makes her more qualified to lead than her Democratic rival.
During a speech on Iraq last week, Mrs Clinton said of the March 1996 trip: “I remember landing under sniper fire. There was supposed to be some kind of a greeting ceremony at the airport, but instead we just ran with our heads down to get into the vehicles to get to our base.”
But the video of her arrival shows Mrs Clinton and her daughter Chelsea smiling and waving as they walked at a leisurely pace across the tarmac from a cargo plane, stopping to shake hands with Bosnia’s acting president and listen while an 8-year-old girl read out a poem.
The comedian Sinbad, who along with singer Sheryl Crowe accompanied Mrs Clinton on the goodwill mission, told The Washington Post he had no recollection either of the threat or reality of gunfire.
CBS, whose correspondent also attended the trip, said Mrs Clinton had "greatly misstated" what happened. The news network added: "There was no sniper fire either when Clinton visited two army outposts, where she posed for photos. And no sniper fire back at the base, where she sang in a USO show starring Sinbad and Sheryl Crowe."
Mrs Clinton insisted yesterday that she had simply misspoken, characterising the false claim as a “minor blip” among the “millions of words” she spoke every day.
Asked about the issue during a meeting with the Philadelphia Daily News’ editorial board, she said: “I went to 80 countries, you know. I gave contemporaneous accounts, I wrote about a lot of this in my book.
“You know, I think that, a minor blip, you know, if I said something that, you know, I say a lot of things – millions of words a day – so if I misspoke, that was just a misstatement,” she said.
But Tommy Vietor, a spokesman for the Obama camp, argued that the claim was not simply a slip of the tongue as it was made in “prepared remarks” during the Iraq speech.
“When you make a false claim that’s in your prepared remarks, it’s not misspeaking, it’s misleading,” Mr Vietor said.
“It’s part of a troubling pattern of Senator Clinton inflating her foreign policy experience."
Howard Wolfson, a Clinton spokesman, counterclaimed that the comments were made ahead of the speech proper, and accused the Obama campaign of raising the issue only because “they have nothing positive to say about their candidate”.
Amid a slew of mocking news reports and replays of the contradictory footage, he insisted that the trip, designed as a morale-booster for US troops maintaining the peace after Bosnia’s civil war, had taken Mrs Clinton into a “potential combat zone".
He recalled the New York senator’s book, “Living History,” in which she described a welcoming ceremony at Bosnia’s Tuzla Airbase which was curtailed due to the risk of attack.
“Due to reports of snipers in the hills around the airstrip, we were forced to cut short an event on the Tarmac with local children, though we did have time to meet them and their teachers and to learn how hard they had worked during the war to continue classes in any safe spot they could find,” she wrote.
Mr Wolfson said: “That is what she wrote in her book. That is what she has said many, many times and on one occasion she misspoke.”
However the issue threatened to overshadow Mrs Clinton’s attempt to bring voters’ attention back to the faltering economy, as she outlined her plan to prevent the US mortgage crisis spiralling into a full-blown recession.
Mrs Clinton’s recollections of her involvement in several foreign crises, which she claims leave her more prepared than her rival to be commander-in-chief, have come under scrutiny since the publication last week of more than 11,000 pages of schedules from her years in the White House.
The documents have so far failed to shed much light on her assertions that as First Lady she played a key role in bringing peace to Northern Ireland or in opening Macedonia’s borders to Kosovo refugees.
They will no doubt be further dissected as the rivals try to land a knock-out blow in an increasingly nasty Democratic contest. Mr Obama currently leads the overall delegate count with 1,620 to Mrs Clinton’s 1,499, but neither is likely to reach the 2,024 needed to clinch the nomination, so must convince superdelegates – senior Democrats free to vote for any candidate at the party’s August convention – that they are the most capable of taking on John McCain in the November election.
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


Overseas contacts and local business information

A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


Our Credit Clinic has free help and advice
2007
£47,700
2007
£41,899
2008
£41,445
Great car insurance deals online
£25,510 – 32,000
Transport for London
London
£50k
NHS
Nationwide
£
£30k OTE
Meltwater News
Nationwide
100K
Confidential
London
5% below developer pre-launch price!
Luxury Appts, beautiful gardens w/ Thames views
Great Homes Available on a shared Ownership Basis
Great Investment, River Views
By Funway – Thailand
from £589pp
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
It would be interesting to see what an interviewer would say about a job candidate who made similar statements. Do you think I could be hired by anyone if I had made similar statements?
bob jones, bosnia, seriavo
If I may reply (so late) to Tommy A. First, I accept your specific examples -- which may nonetheless embody misunderstandings. How do we know how intimately & deeply she was involved in these things through her own husband -- in a wifely role. From her early years she was intimately associated with Bill Clinton's rise (from "nothing" practically). I think it a mistake to suppose that wives do not participate in & learn from their husbands' experience. Mine did in a marriage of 49 years -- I still value her insights.
Ernest Werner, Trumansburg NY , USA
here are a few examples of "misspeaking"
"I went to the movies saturday" ... when it was actually sunday.
"the game comes on at 9"... when it actually comes on at 8.
"Im so glad to be here in Los Angeles"... when you are actually in San Diego...
THAT is misspeaking.
If you have NEVER in your LIFE been on a plane doing evasive maneuvers and being sniped at Mrs. Clinton... the Bosnia story is not a blip or a mis-statement. It is a LIE.
Furthermore... since she says millions of words a day... maybe she should take her own advice that WORDS MATTER.
Ernest... exactly WHAT genuine experience are you referring to? Ireland peace process - proven false. Bosnia - proven false. SCHIP - proven false. her negotiation of the release of Macedonian refugees - proven false (they were released the day BEFORE she arrived). Instrumental in 90's economic growth - she didn't even have clearance to the meetings. Opposition of NAFTA - she attended several meetings on how to implement NAFTA.
Come on now
Tommy A, Manassas, VA
All I really want to know - Did Hillary EVER leave a plane under sniper fire? This is important. It could be somewhat excusable if she just had a brain-hiccup' and confused a time and place, but if she NEVER came under fire and had to do the 'duck and run' thing............ ????
Mike M., Canton, Ohio
Bill Clinton had a 'misspeak' about having sex in the oval office.
Hillary Clinton had a 'misspeak' about sniper fire. What a great team they make.
If she is the best option for president of the USA God help the rest of the world.
Mike, Hobart, Australia
This is far worse than the contreversy that surrounded Rev Wright. No one has ever noticed Mr Obama making such controversial remarks as the Rev (to be fair to Rev Wright, a lot of Evangelical Preachers said after 9/11 that it was God's punishment, including a lot of White preachers). Obama's only "crime", if one can be attributed to him under the circumstances, is that he attended a Church where the Preacher made very controversial (but not illegal remarks). Mrs Clitton, on the other hand, has delibrately misled the public seeking to gain from that.
How could she call it a "blip"? That is very scary! Men, she is planning to take the most powerful post on earth, and calls misleading the public a "blip".
We already have enough "blips" about WMDs. No more "blips" please!
Tom, London,
"Okay, Clinton exaggerated a fact:"
Can somebody provide a few crates of dictionaries for the Clinton campaign?
Repeat after me... in a Bill Clinton voice... "they did not have shots at that woman"
Joe, brussels, belgium
Sandra,
Obama's campaign has been and always will be about moving onward and upward. It is Clinton who keeps dragging them down to her level. If you 'slip up' that easily your just asking for it.
Sathiji, London,
Mrs. Clinton has been very deliberately inflating her resume especially the "experience" section. Truth is she is no more qualified to answer scary phone-calls now than she was when she was First Lady.
The recent interview with the comedian Sinbad who accompanied Clinton as she moved in tactical-bounds, using fire-and-movement crossing the enfiladed tarmac of Tuzla was hilarious:-
In her Iowa stump speech, Clinton also said, "We used to say in the White House that if a place is too dangerous, too small or too poor, send the First Lady."
Say what? As Sinbad put it: "What kind of president would say, 'Hey, man, I can't go 'cause I might get shot so I'm going to send my wife...oh, and take a guitar player and a comedian with you.'"
Laugh? I almost cried!!!
Robert , Mobile, Alabama
The apparently convincing and nonchalant manner in which Mrs Clinton 'misspoke' about her experiences in Bosnia is only matched by her equally dismissive explanation for being caught lying!
It seems that this candidate for the most powerful elected office on the planet cannot distinguish between fact and fiction. The obvious question is can we believe anything she has said in the past or will say in the future? I cannot understand how the Amercan voting public can be taken in by this woman.
I wonder if she stays up until 3:00AM imagining these experiences?
Donovan Wright, Reading, Berkshire
If by millions a words a day she means at least 2 million words. Then in that case she utters over 2 words every second of every minute of every hour of the day. Even when she is asleep!
Or, in yet another 2 million word day, has she mispoken again?
Paul, Cincinnati, Ohio
I find it sad that Obama's campaign has nothing better to do than bash Hillary. Shouldn't he be spending his time coming up with a solution to the imminent economic recession rather than accusing her?
Okay, Clinton exaggerated a fact: do you mean to tell me that Barack has never flat-out lied about bills he worked on or programs he was involved in? Hillary isn't a perfect person. If one misstatement is the worst thing Obama can come up with about her, then she's a lot better politician than most others I can think of.
sandra, basking ridge, nj
If this can happen during the day, what 'mispeaks' could happen at 3-00 am?
If this had been the only occasion she 'mispoke' on the subject, well, maybe it could be understood. But as I understand the reports, it's happened before (twice) on this same subject.
In this case it seems to be not saying what you believe, but believing what you say.
Time to 'bow out gracefully' Hilary, before you totally destroy the Dems chance of winning.
Keith, Dalsland, Sweden
A million words a day would 17.36 words per second, every second for 16 hours a day. Yet another exaggeration or just pure stupidity? I think a president should have at least a marginal grasp of numbers.
Omar, Santa Rosa, CA
What a nasty bunch of people are under the Obama umbrella!
It is just snipe, snipe, snipe!
After watching, his interview with Larry King, I am not the least bit awed, by this phony thin skinned candidate.
'Me thinks, the gentleman, doth protest, too much'.
This final, nasty dig at Hillary Clinton, is, for me, just a step too far!
It reminds me, of the awful in fighting, that, occurred at 10 Downing Street, during, Blair's reign!
prudence eely bond mcguire, LONDON, ENGLAND UK.
Ernest wrote: "Hillary's very genuine experience is constantly being run down by her detractors."
Actually, they are being run into and run down by reality. The Empress wears no clothes.
Chris, Arlington, VA, USA
Oh dear what is the matter with Hillary's memory,this sort of statement is just plain wrong and sadly it reduces her credibility,after all what is so terrible about saying she has not been involved in US foreign policy,surely that must be a plus.
margot parker, Kettering, UK
Hillary said: âYou know, I think that, a minor blip, you know, if I said something that, you know, I say a lot of things â millions of words a day â so if I misspoke, that was just a misstatement,â she said.
I pose a question to Hillary. Members of the jury (i.e., millions of voters) are advised to listen:
"Since you say millions of words every day, is it safe to assume that 90% (okay make that more than 50%) of what you say are misstatements?
Greg, Austin,
She speaks "Millions of words a day"? WOW! THAT'S PRETTY AMAZING!
Sol Bales, Des Moines, IA
Yet another minor embarrassment -- all of our candidates have stumbled into embarrassmets. Now that I am old & wise, I find that we exaggerate when we recommend ourselves. Once inflated, our tale becomes part of our history. It's what we wish we were.
Hillary's very genuine experience is constantly being run down by her detractors, but she is certainly a well-qualified woman.
Ernest Werner, Trumansburg NY , USA
"Misspoke"? That's cute...I like that. Next time I tell a blatant lie, I'll use that and see if it works.
Why aren't news stations replaying this over and over and over again?
Rain, Temple, PA
I'd say if her phone rang at 3 am, she might think it was sniper fire.
David, Amstelveen, Netherlands
Fudging a bit on how involved one is on a bill is one thing, making up sniper fire and imminent danger is quite another. Especially when you are using this and other statements that have come under question (Ireland work) to attack your apponent as being untested and not knowing how to answer a phone (look at SNL's take on this) http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/03/16/snl-shows-blatant-antisp_n_91732.html
The photos and footage donât even look like she is wearing bullet proof vests etc. And Bill would send his wife AND daughter into such danger? For someone without a security clearance in the White House, Hillary sure thinks she was involved in a lot of sensitive and cloak and dagger stuff! Why doesn't someone in the press ask her point blank if she EVER had to duck sniper fire⦠if not then this clearly isnât a miss-speak but a fabrication.
arthurW from VA, Cville, Virginia